Gaten Matarazzo, who plays the pudding-loving Dustin on Netflix’s Stranger Things, is a great singer. Remember when we heard him sing the national anthem at a MLB game? He crushed it. He’s also in a band called Work in Progress, and they performed recently on the Jersey Shore at the Stone Pony near where Matarazzo grew up.

He sang on a number of songs, including covers of Foo Fighter’s “Everlong” and “Porch” by Pearl Jam. YouTube user vivalavix was there and recorded Matarazzo and company performing the covers. Also on the setlist was Fall Out Boy’s “Sugar We’re Going Down,” which Matarazzo sang alongside his sister. You can watch that video here on YouTube from user BeccaRaptor94.

Stranger Things Season 2 premiered just before Halloween last year, and it was a huge hit. Incredibly, around one third of the the streamer’s US subscribers watched it. So it’s no surprise that Netflix greenlit a third season, though we don’t know when it’ll premiere or what the story will be.

For more on Season 2, check out GameSpot’s hub for the show to find reviews, theories, and everything else you need to know. In other news, a drummer rips the show’s main theme with this killer cover.